Only the Best

The plant team in Wausau, Wis., made energy efficiency a top priority when selecting new equipment for a $2 million upgrade.
Only the Best

Interested in Energy?

Get Energy articles, news and videos right in your inbox! Sign up now.

Energy + Get Alerts

In completing a $2 million upgrade to the Wausau Wastewater Treatment Plant, the staff did everything possible to improve energy efficiency with the new equipment.

Planning began three years ago and the project went online in fall 2011. "The existing blower equipment was dated, inefficient and breaking down," says Ken Ligman, project manager from the Becher-Hoppe Associates engineering firm in Wausau. The 8.2 mgd (design) advanced activated sludge plant serves Wausau, the City of Schofield, and part of a neighboring township. Its average flow is 4 mgd.

The old plant had three positive displacement blowers installed in 1970. The motors and two biogas-fueled engines were from 1989. "The engines required an awful lot of maintenance, and replacement parts were getting hard to find," says Ligman. "Money had to be spent. With a little foresight, we think we spent it wisely."

Careful selection

The city purchased all the equipment separately, rather than as part of a turnkey package. That enabled the staff to take proposals from various suppliers to find the best combination of technology. Ghidorzi Construction Co. of Wausau was the general contractor.

"We looked at engine-driven blowers, but it was more cost-effective to go with microturbines," Ligman says. Capstone 65 kW microturbines produce electricity that is used on site. Three Turblex 3,400 cfm blowers (Siemens Water Technologies) with variable-frequency drives (VFDs) provide aeration capacity.

"The microturbines use the gas the engines would have used to generate electricity, but they also generate hot water, which is used to heat the buildings and the anaerobic digester," says Ligman. Expected net energy savings amount to about 900,000 kWh a year and about 77,000 therms of natural gas, equating to $130,000 a year at current utility rates.

The gas scrubbing equipment came from Unison. "The gas skid was placed in a separate building, and the existing 2-foot-high concrete bases for the blower engines were cut down to make the blowers more accessible for operators," Ligman says.

The blowers are paced off the dissolved oxygen levels in the aeration tanks. The VFDs are controlled by the existing programmable logic controllers (PLCs) and SCADA systems, which were modified to account for the new machinery.

"For most of the day, a single blower runs at half capacity," says Ligman. "There are a couple of peak occurrences during the day, but not every day, when a second blower is used." When that happens, both blowers start at minimum capacity and adjust the operating speed based on dissolved oxygen.

"In summer, we'll need two blowers much more frequently," adds wastewater superintendent Dave Erickson. Other positive side effects of the project, especially for operators, are that the blower room is much quieter with the new blowers, and they don't have to spend as much time working on the blower engines.

Improved aeration

Funding was aided by grants from Wisconsin's Focus on Energy program. The aeration improvements garnered a $100,000 grant, while a $135,000 grant helped pay for the microturbines. The local utility, Wisconsin Public Service, provided a $25,000 incentive payment while two planning grants, totaling $9,200, were also secured for the project.

Half of the plant's aeration tanks were updated as part of the upgrade. "We replaced the existing ceramic fine-bubble diffusers in three of the six tanks with Sanitaire membrane fine-bubble diffusers (Xylem)," says Ligman. The plant only uses three tanks at a time. New dissolved oxygen sensors were also installed in those three tanks, and airflow metering was added.

The project also included several minor changes, such as replacing 30-year-old slide gate valves in the aeration tanks along with drain and mud valves, and replacing corroded concrete effluent boxes. That added to the cost but helped improve plant operations.

Erickson says the plant will be saving energy and money while getting the same high-quality wastewater treatment for which it is known.



Discussion

Comments on this site are submitted by users and are not endorsed by nor do they reflect the views or opinions of COLE Publishing, Inc. Comments are moderated before being posted.